Natalie Portman Elizabeth
Antonio Banderas Tonio
Cate Blanchett Nancy
Christian Bale Rick
Imogen Poots Della
Nick Offerman Scott
Joel Kinnaman Errol
Jocelin Donahue Jocelin
Shea Whigham Jim
Jason Clarke Johnny
Cherry Jones Ruth
Theo Bongani Ndyalvane Party Guest (uncredited)