O Come, All Ye Faithful
8.5
 The Vampire Diaries, S4E9, O Come, All Ye Faithful 13 years ago
Gone Abie Gone
5.8
 The Simpsons, S24E4, Gone Abie Gone 13 years ago
The Pact
7.8
 Criminal Minds, S8E2, The Pact 14 years ago
Gone, Gone, Gone
6.9
 True Blood, S5E10, Gone, Gone, Gone 14 years ago
In the Beginning
6.6
 True Blood, S5E7, In the Beginning 14 years ago
Beefsquatch
7.6
 Bob's Burgers, S2E9, Beefsquatch 14 years ago
Divining Rod
7.6
 Criminal Minds, S7E21, Divining Rod 14 years ago
Synchronized Swimming
7.4
 Bob's Burgers, S2E3, Synchronized Swimming 14 years ago
Snake Eyes
7
 Criminal Minds, S7E13, Snake Eyes 14 years ago
Self-Fulfilling Prophecy
8.5
 Criminal Minds, S7E9, Self-Fulfilling Prophecy 14 years ago
Hope
7.8
 Criminal Minds, S7E8, Hope 14 years ago
Replaceable You
6.3
 The Simpsons, S23E4, Replaceable You 14 years ago
Treehouse of Horror XXII
6.1
 The Simpsons, S23E3, Treehouse of Horror XXII 14 years ago
Dorado Falls
7.7
 Criminal Minds, S7E3, Dorado Falls 15 years ago
The Birthday
8
 The Vampire Diaries, S3E1, The Birthday 15 years ago
Lobsterfest
7.5
 Bob's Burgers, S1E12, Lobsterfest 15 years ago
As I Lay Dying
8.7
 The Vampire Diaries, S2E22, As I Lay Dying 15 years ago
The Big Bang Theory
7.7
 Family Guy, S9E16, The Big Bang Theory 15 years ago
The Sun Also Rises
8.8
 The Vampire Diaries, S2E21, The Sun Also Rises 15 years ago
The Real Housewives of Fat Tony
6.7
 The Simpsons, S22E19, The Real Housewives of Fat Tony 15 years ago
Klaus
8.9
 The Vampire Diaries, S2E19, Klaus 15 years ago
Brothers & Sisters
6.8
 Family Guy, S9E15, Brothers & Sisters 15 years ago
Art Crawl
7.7
 Bob's Burgers, S1E8, Art Crawl 15 years ago
Bed & Breakfast
7.2
 Bob's Burgers, S1E7, Bed & Breakfast 15 years ago